The modification of racial bias in preschool children

Publication Year
1975

Type

Journal Article
Abstract

Conducted 2 experiments to study previous reports of a pro-Euro-American-anti-Afro-American racial bias in preschool children of both races. An attempt to modify this bias using the Preschool Racial Attitude Measure II (PRAM) is reported. Exp I involved 39 Euro- and Afro-American preschool children and employed operant learning principles to modify the bias via a teaching machine procedure which provided reinforcement for pro-Afri/anti-Euro (E+/A-) responses. Following training, Ss showed a reduction in E+/A- bias on a test procedure not associated with the training. Follow-up testing of 30 Ss 1 yr after the posttest revealed a tendency for the E+ bias to be partially reestablished. Exp II involved 70 Euro-American kindergarten children and was concerned with the modification of E+/A- bias via a classroom curriculum procedure and the possible influence of the race of the teacher. The experimental curriculum, designed to develop positive associations to dark-skinned persons and to the colors black and brown, had no effect on E+/N- bias, nor was the race of teacher a variable of significance. (21 ref) (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved)

Journal
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
Volume
20
Pages
193-205
Type of Article
Journal Article
Full text

The following is an excerpt of the intervention methodology. For more information, please see the full text of the article on the publisher's website or through your institution's library.

EXPERIMENT 1

Subjects for this study were Euro- and Afro-American preschool children enrolled in a racially integrated church-related kindergarten in Winston-Salem, NC, during the 1972-73 school year. [...] In Phase I of the study, the children were administered a modified version of the PRAM II procedure (half of the test was given in standard interview fashion and half via machine administration) in order to assess the equivalence of the two modes of presentation and to establish baseline levels of racial bias. In Phase II, children displaying appreciable E+/A- bias were trained via a teaching machine procedure which employed the half of the PRAM II pictures and stories previously used in the machine administration and reinforced unconventional (E- and A+) responses. In Phase III, the children were again administered the nontrained half of PRAM II in interview fashion. In Phase IV, the children were contacted 1 yr later and were administered the full PRAM II procedure in interview fashion. [...]

EXPERIMENT 2

Subjects for this study were 70 Euro-American preschool children (mean age 68 mo) enrolled in two church-related kindergartens in Winston-Salem, NC. [...] The study employed the PRAM II procedure in a pre-postassessment design to determine the effects on racial bias of two variables: (1) participation in a race- and color-related curriculum vs a control curriculum; and (2) the race of the teachers administering the special curricula (two Euro teachers vs two Afro teachers vs one Euro and one Afro). [...] The general design was thus a 2 x 3 factorial, with an additional untreated control group.

METHOD

Precurriculum Assessment Period All subjects were administered the 12-item Series A of PRAM II and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, form b ted in two 45min sessions per week, for a total of 8 wk, or approximately 12 hr of classroom contact time. [...] The teachers for the special curricula were three Euro- and three Afro-American undergraduate college women, who had had some previous experience, but no special training, in working with preschool children. [...] In the race-related curriculum school, the children in each of the three race-of-teacher groups were presented the curriculum material in the same format each session. In the first session each week, the children were read a story relating to skin color, the colors black and brown, interaction between Afro and Euro children, or a “Black hero.” Following the story, the children asked questions and discussed the story. A related art activity was then introduced employing black, white, and brown construction paper, paint, and other art materials. The second weekly session followed essentially the same format as the first, sometimes involving the completion of unfinished art activities or the introduction of a new story. At the end of every session, the children played a variation of Yancey’s black-white box game. For this game, the children were shown a white can and a black can and were told that one of the cans would give them a surprise. Each session, each child got to choose which can he wanted, the black or the white. In the black can was a slip of paper directing the teachers to give the children a piece of candy or chewing gum. In the white can was a neutral informational message, usually about the weather. In the nonrace-related curriculum school, the curriculum material followed a format similar to the race-related curriculum, but with no racially oriented material involved. [...]

Postcurriculum Assessment Period The postassessment was conducted approximately 3 wk following the end of the curriculum period. [...]. Each child was administered the 12-item Series B of PRAM II, followed by the Color Meaning Test II.

Type of Prejudice/Bias
Country
Method