Reducing interethnic bias through real-life and literary encounters: The interplay between face-to-face and vicarious contact in high school classrooms

Author
Publication Year
2018

Type

Journal Article
Abstract

Literary intergroup contact—reading about ingroup members’ encounters with outgroup members—is a useful first step toward the reduction of intergroup bias in settings with limited face-to-face intergroup contact, such as ethnically segregated schools. What, however, happens to this bias-reduction potential of interethnic stories in classrooms rife with face-to-face interactions between ethnically diverse students? And does this interaction between literary and face-to-face contact function similarly 1) for ethnic-majority students and ethnic-minority students and 2) for affective and cognitive measures of interethnic bias? A between-subjects experiment was conducted among 977 students in 63 classrooms in a Belgian province with a history of Moroccan migration. Half of the classes read from a ‘white-Belgian-majority’ book (control group), the others from a ‘Moroccan-Belgian’ book (literary contact group). Multilevel regression analyses indicated two opposing trends: 1) more face-to-face contact with Moroccan classmates strengthened the effect of literary interethnic contact on self-identified Belgian students’ attitude toward Moroccans, but 2) more face-to-face contact with Belgian-majority classmates reduced the effect of literary interethnic contact on the attitude toward Belgians of self-identified non-Belgian students. Moreover, the Moroccan-Belgian book was associated with a lesser awareness of discrimination against Moroccan youngsters for students who did not identify as Belgian in classes with few students of Moroccan descent, and for students who felt (very) Belgian in classes with relatively many students of Moroccan descent. The quality of face-to-face intergroup contact is offered as a post-hoc explanation.

Journal
International Journal of Intercultural Relations
Volume
63
Pages
53–67
Type of Article
Journal Article
Full text

The following is an excerpt of the intervention methodology. For more information, please see the full text of the article on the publisher's website or through your institution's library.

Sample [...] The sample focused on three cities—Antwerp itself, Mechelen, and Boom—with two to three times more people of Moroccan descent than the Belgian average. [...] A total of 1025 students in 63 classes participated, with on average 15.51 students per class and 65.13 students per school. Of these, 977 surveys were deemed valid. Across schools, 17% of the students had at least one parent born in Morocco. Exactly half of the students were male (50%). They were aged 13–21, with most aged 15 (45%) or 16 (35%). [...]

Procedure In spring 2016, the participating classes read book fragments together out loud during two course hours (100 min) of their Dutch class. [...] The class then read from one of two relatively easy-to-read adolescent novels by well-known Flemish author Dirk Bracke. Book A—read by 48% of the classes—is the ‘white-Belgian-majority’ novel Blinde woede (‘Blind rage’). It describes how 17-year-old Lena—a talented singer who is gradually going blind due to a hereditary disease—deals with school, love, and friendship issues. The book also has two male protagonists, but no ethnic-minority characters. [...] Book B—read by 52% of the classes—is the ‘Moroccan-Belgian’ novel Henna op je huid (‘Henna on your skin’). It tells the story of 15-year-old secondgeneration Moroccan girl Touria and her brothers, who negotiate between their family’s culture and encounters with Belgian-majority members. Although these encounters are mostly friendships among peers, some describe situations of discrimination. [...] The participating classes were thus first randomly distributed over the white-Belgian-majority and Moroccan-Belgian conditions, and as a second step matched so that classes in both conditions would be similar in their distribution of the class’ track, percentage of male students, and percentages of students from non-Western and—more specifically—Moroccan backgrounds. A ‘posttest only’ design was used: the students only completed an anonymous survey during the Dutch class following the experiment (usually one to three days later). [...]

Measures

Dependent variables Students’ attitude toward Moroccans and attitude toward Belgians were measured via two feeling thermometers with 0° implying very negative feelings and 100° very positive feelings. [...] In addition, students’ awareness of discrimination against Moroccan youngsters was measured with four five-point-scale items [...].

Independent variables As mentioned, students’ ethnicity was approached subjectively, allowing them to self-identify as Belgian, Moroccan, both or neither. [...] At the classroom level, the independent variables were the two types of interethnic contact. Vicarious interethnic contact through book reading was operationalized through the experimental manipulation use of a Moroccan-Belgian book. [...] The second type of interethnic contact, face-to-face contact, was operationalized with two continuous variables. Which of these two was used in the analyses depends on the hypothesis under scrutiny. Students’ face-to-face contact with Moroccan classmates was measured through the class Moroccan concentration, which is the class percentage of students with at least one parent born in Morocco. [...]

Control variables Three class-level controls were used [...]. These include teachers’ ethnic background [...] and age [...]. [...] Finally, the class’ track was also considered [...]. In addition, three student-level controls were used. Firstly, students’ sex [...]. Secondly, their reading skill was measured [...]. Finally, students’ parental cultural status was included [...].

Manipulation check A manipulation check was added to test that differences between the Moroccan-Belgian and white-Belgian-majority condition could not be ascribed to one book being more engaging than the other. [...]

Type of Prejudice/Bias
Country
Method